Business Cabana
The Penny Pub is a bar in Bay Shore — a candidate spot to gather, see who’s around, and let something easy happen.
79 West Main Street, Bay Shore, NY, 11706
In Bay Shore
Connect with this CabanaStart a Soak here
Add this Cabana to your map and see related Soaks, updates, and recommendations.
UnclaimedIs this your business? Claim it →
Details may be unverified. Help confirm what’s accurate.
No from-scratch tax
No regulars yet — be the first.
No Soaks here yet. Start one for people to gather.
Start a Soak hereYou’ll be indoors, it’s mid-priced.
On hand here: food on site, a bar.
If you’re finding your people in Bay Shore, start somewhere like this.
🔊 Lively — you can talk freely, lean in to be heard.
Food on site · Serves alcohol
Auto-imported from OpenStreetMap — address & details unverified. Help confirm what’s accurate.
Sign in to add accessibility info — it takes a few taps and helps the next person.
It’s mid-priced.
It tends to be loud.
Yes, and a bar.
Know a place worth gathering at? Add a Cabana →
Islip, New York
Destination Unknown Beer Company
Bay Shore, New York
Loews Bay Shore Twin (Historic)
Bay Shore, New York
Islip, New York